Home / Blog / TRACKS OR TIRES: HOW TO CHOOSE THE BEST LOADER FOR THE JOB

TRACKS OR TIRES: HOW TO CHOOSE THE BEST LOADER FOR THE JOB

TRACKS OR TIRES: HOW TO CHOOSE THE BEST LOADER FOR THE JOB


Compact track loaders

, or CTLs, are one of the lowest operating cost equipment options. They
have become increasingly popular in recent years, surpassing sales of

compact wheel loaders

. Despite the boom in popularity, contractors should consider their
intended application before choosing between tracks or tires. Let’s take a
look at some of the differences between track loaders vs. wheel loaders and
why your business would benefit from one over another.

 

COMPACT WHEEL LOADERS

 

For applications on hard, smooth surfaces like concrete, wheel loaders are
the better choice. Four tires offer better traction on hard surfaces and
handle curbs and other road obstacles with ease. They cause less damage to
grass and dirt than tracks but don’t perform well in muddy conditions. For
contractors who do the majority of their work in existing developments with
roadways, a wheeled loader works best.

 

Another point to note, compact wheel loaders are less expensive than their
tracked counterparts, and replacement tires are significantly cheaper than
replacement tracks.

 

COMPACT TRACK LOADERS

 

CTLs are ideal for suboptimal ground or soil conditions. With tracks, the
weight of the machine is spread over more area, creating lower ground
pressure that prevents sinking even on wet soil. Tracked loaders easily
cross over narrow trenches and climb over logs or other obstacles. In wet
or rough conditions, CTLs dig more easily, push with more power, and
perform better. For contractors who primarily work on new construction
projects, a CTL is your best bet.

 

Upgrading from a canopy to a cab allows operators to work in just about any
site or weather conditions. “Cabbed CTLs are becoming increasingly popular
due to their Swiss army knife-like capabilities,” said Matt Wolf, Equipment
Territory Manager for Papé Machinery Construction & Forestry. “An owner
can use it on multiple site applications. This versatility allows the owner
to recoup their purchase quickly while building a more diverse book of
business opportunities.”

 

While CTLs are typically more expensive than a comparable wheel loader,
they are a worthwhile investment if you are regularly up against rough
conditions. Replacement tracks are costly, but with proper

track maintenance

and care, they shouldn’t need to be replaced often.

 

Over The Tire Rubber Tracks

 

If you are still stuck on the tracks vs. wheels decision,

over the tire rubber tracks

, give you the best of both worlds. This

product

is a removable track option that can be added to a wheel loader as needed
so you can use the equipment for all applications. Having the option of
both tracks and wheels is an optimal solution for contractors who want the
flexibility to take on road projects as well as projects in dirt or mud
without having to incur the expense of owning two machines.

 

Over the tire rubber tracks will offer increased stability, flotation, and
traction in wet conditions, but they do have some limitations. They will
not perform as well as a CTL for grading tasks, so if that is your primary
goal, it would be better to go with a CTL and

rent a wheel loader

for the occasional road project.

 

Stop by your

nearest Papé Machinery Construction and Forestry location

in Washington, Oregon, California, or Nevada to see our compact wheel
loaders and compact track loaders for sale

Related Content

Wirtgen Milling Machines for Pavement Resurfacing: Late-Season Road Repairs

Wirtgen Milling Machines for Pavement Resurfacing: Late-Season Road Repairs

As construction season winds down, time is limited to complete resurfacing projects before colder, wetter weather makes paving more difficult. Shorter daylight hours, lower pavement temperatures, changing weather conditions, and tighter shutdown windows can reduce the margin for error between milling and final compaction.  The milling pass has to do more than remove asphalt. It…

Papé Machinery Named Best Construction Machine Dealer in Deschutes County for 2026

Papé Machinery Named Best Construction Machine Dealer in Deschutes County for 2026

Papé Machinery Construction & Forestry is proud to be recognized as the Best Construction Machine Dealer in Deschutes County for 2026 by BusinessRate. This recognition is based on verified Google Reviews and customer feedback, rather than nominations or applications. Our team earned first place with a score of 213 out of 300, reflecting our commitment…

John Deere 210 P-Tier Excavator: New Features, Technology, and Performance

John Deere 210 P-Tier Excavator: New Features, Technology, and Performance

The John Deere 210 P-Tier Mid-Size Excavator brings updated technology, improved operator comfort, and enhanced serviceability to one of the most versatile equipment classes on the jobsite. Designed for utility work, trenching, site preparation, road construction, and general earthmoving, the 210 P-Tier combines digging performance with features that help operators work more efficiently. With the…

New Equipment

At Papé Machinery Construction & Forestry, we offer top-tier equipment from trusted brands like John Deere. Our selection of excavators, dozers, and forestry machinery delivers reliable performance for construction and land management.

Used Equipment

At Papé Machinery Construction & Forestry, we offer quality used equipment from trusted brands like John Deere. From excavators and loaders to a variety of attachments, our inventory delivers reliable, cost-effective solutions for your job site needs.

Expert Support Get In Touch

Our team is here to help you find the right solution.